Shorts Playbook

Home › Guides › How to Brief a Video Editor for Short Clips

How to Brief a Video Editor for Short Clips

A good brief does the thinking the editor cannot do for you: which moments matter and why. Everything that is a craft decision stays with the editor, and the brief says so plainly.

Send the full episode, not a trimmed export

Send the complete episode at the highest quality you have, including the raw camera angles if the show was recorded with more than a single camera. The editor needs room before and after each moment to find a clean cut point, and a pre-trimmed file takes that room away.

Include the transcript as a text file with timecodes, even a rough machine transcript. The editor will search it to locate lines you mention, so a searchable transcript saves a round of questions about where something is.

Mark each clip by transcript, not by feel

For every clip you want, write down the exact line where the clip should begin and the exact line where it should end, pasted from the transcript. Add the rough timecode next to each line so the editor can jump straight there. Describe the hook in a sentence: what the viewer hears in the opening moment and why someone who has not heard the episode would keep watching.

State the point of the clip in your own words, as if explaining it to a friend. The editor uses that sentence to decide what can be trimmed inside the clip without losing the idea, which is the main judgment you are paying for.

Name files and clips so nothing gets confused

Use a single naming pattern for the whole project and put it at the top of the brief. A pattern that works: show short name, episode identifier, a short topic word for the clip, then a version tag. Keep the clip's topic word identical in the brief, in the file name, and in your feedback so every message refers to the same thing.

Ask the editor to return finished files using the same pattern with the version tag incremented. When a revision arrives, you know at a glance which clip it is and which round it belongs to, and you never overwrite a file you meant to keep.

Give the frame and the safe zones once

Tell the editor the aspect ratios you need and the platforms each clip is going to, and let them handle the reframing. YouTube Shorts can be up to 3 minutes long and square or vertical[1]. If you want a portrait master that can be cropped later, say so in the brief rather than requesting separate cuts clip by clip.

Point the editor to published safe zones so text and captions stay clear of interface overlays. Instagram's Reels ad spec is 9:16 at 1440 by 2560 pixels and asks you to keep about 14 percent at the top, 35 percent at the bottom and 6 percent on each side clear of text[2]. TikTok's In-Feed ad spec recommends 9:16 at a minimum of 540 by 960 pixels and notes the safe zone depends on dimensions and caption length, with template files published for it[3]. Attach or link those templates in the brief and the editor can check their own work.

Decide how captions are made and checked

Say in the brief whether captions are burned into the video, uploaded as a separate file, or both. The W3C describes captions as a text version of the speech and non-speech audio needed to understand the content, and says good captions are synchronized, identify speakers when it is not obvious, and describe important non-speech sounds[4]. For an interview clip that usually means speaker labels when the camera does not show who is talking.

If you plan to rely on platform captions, build a review step into the brief. YouTube's automatic captions come from speech recognition, their quality varies, and YouTube says to review and edit them[5]. Decide who does that review, you or the editor, and write it down so it is not skipped.

Leave the craft to the editor

Once the start line, end line, hook, and point are written, stop. Exact cut frames, pacing, the removal of filler and silence, where to put a jump cut, music under the speech, and whether a line reads better with a text card are the editor's calls. Say in the brief that these are theirs, and that you want their judgment rather than a literal transcription of your markers.

If something is a hard constraint, label it as a constraint. Everything not labeled that way is a preference, and the editor is free to override a preference when the footage argues otherwise. This single distinction removes most of the back and forth in later rounds.

Give feedback the same way you gave the brief

When the initial cut comes back, watch it on a phone with the sound on, then with the sound off. Note anything that fails with a timecode from the delivered clip and the transcript line it affects, in the same format you used for the brief. Avoid feelings-only notes; say what you saw and what you expected instead.

Group all notes for a clip in a single message and send them together. Piecemeal feedback forces the editor to reopen the project repeatedly, and it is the most common reason a simple clip takes more rounds than it should.

This is a working method drawn from editing practice, not a rule. Adjust the structure to your editor and your show, and keep the parts that save you a round of revisions.

More guides

Sources

  1. YouTube Help: Upload YouTube Shorts, read 2026-09-30.
  2. Meta Ads Guide: video ad specs on Instagram Reels, read 2026-09-30.
  3. TikTok Ads Manager: Auction In-Feed Ads specifications, read 2026-09-30.
  4. W3C WAI: Captions/Subtitles, read 2026-09-30.
  5. YouTube Help: Use automatic captioning, read 2026-09-30.